Control Zoning Strategies for ASHRAE 90.1 & IECC

Proper control zoning is the quiet workhorse behind most successful ASHRAE 90.1 and IECC inspections. When fixtures, sensors, and dimmers are grouped intelligently, code compliance follows almost naturally—and the building actually delivers the promised energy savings.

This article focuses on how to design lighting control zones that satisfy modern energy codes and work for real occupants, with a particular emphasis on warehouse, industrial, and large open commercial spaces using high bays and linear bays.

---

1. What “Control Zoning” Really Means in Energy Codes

1.1 Definition in practice

In the context of ASHRAE 90.1 and the International Energy Conservation Code (IECC), a control zone is:

The group of luminaires that respond together to a given control input (switch, dimmer, occupancy sensor, daylight sensor, or network command).

A single fixture can be a zone, but in most commercial projects a zone is a logical group of fixtures that share:

• Similar task type (e.g., warehouse aisles vs. open pallet storage)
• Similar daylight conditions
• Similar occupancy pattern
• The same code requirement (e.g., must auto-off in 20 minutes, must be daylight-responsive)

1.2 How codes use zoning

Both ASHRAE 90.1 and IECC treat zoning as the enforcement mechanism for mandatory controls:

• Automatic shutoff: Most spaces must be turned off automatically (e.g., via occupancy or schedule) per ASHRAE 90.1-2022, which tightens requirements around controls.
• Area controls: Each enclosed space must have at least one local control.
• Multi-level / continuous dimming: Many spaces must provide multiple lighting levels, typically implemented with 0–10 V or 1–10 V dimming.
• Daylight-responsive zones: Daylit areas near windows and skylights must be controlled separately and dim down automatically under IECC 2024 commercial lighting provisions.

Energy codes do not tell you “put 10 fixtures per sensor.” Instead, they define what behaviors each zone must support: shutoff, step or continuous dimming, daylight response, and sometimes demand response.

1.3 Why zoning is a design decision, not a checkbox

On paper, a single large zone controlled by one occupancy sensor and one photocell might pass a basic code read. In the field, it often fails:

• The forklift driver complains about dark aisles because the sensor is too far away.
• Office staff cover photocells with tape to stop nuisance dimming.
• The facility manager overrides schedules because one “mega-zone” must stay bright for a small active area.

The result: controls are defeated, and the intended savings evaporate.

The goal of this guide is to bridge that gap: design zones that meet ASHRAE 90.1 / IECC and stay usable for years.

---

2. Code-Driven Zoning: What ASHRAE 90.1 and IECC Actually Expect

Before drawing zones, it helps to translate code language into practical rules.

2.1 Mandatory controls by space type

For industrial and warehouse-style spaces, three families of requirements are central:

1. Automatic shutoff
   Both ASHRAE 90.1-2022 and IECC 2024 require automatic shutoff in most commercial spaces. Acceptable methods include:

   • Time scheduling
   • Occupancy or vacancy sensing
   • A combination (e.g., schedule for base, occupancy for partial-on)

2. Multi-level / dimming control
   Modern codes push beyond simple on/off. They usually require:

   • At least one intermediate step between full on and off, or
   • Continuous dimming capability.
     This is where 0–10 V drivers and control wiring become central.

3. Daylight-responsive control
   Daylit areas facing windows or under skylights must typically reduce output automatically when daylight is sufficient, in clearly defined primary and secondary daylight zones.

2.2 Zoning implications

From these control obligations, we can derive zoning principles:

• Every daylit strip (near windows or skylights) must be a distinct control zone—you cannot lump it with deep interior fixtures that never see daylight.
• Each occupancy pattern (e.g., main aisles vs. bulk storage rarely used) should be zoned so its lights can shut off independently.
• If a space has different code rules within it (e.g., a high-bay production floor plus attached low-bay offices), those areas must be separate zones.

Good zoning is essentially code semantics turned into spatial groupings.

---

3. Practical Zoning Patterns That Pass Code and Work in the Field

This section translates code language into real layouts for high-bay and linear bay projects.

3.1 Baseline sizing: how many fixtures per sensor?

Across warehouse and industrial projects, a few rules of thumb consistently hold up:

• For open warehouse bays with high-bay luminaires, aim for 1 occupancy sensor per 200–400 ft² of floor area.
• For narrow aisles or task-intensive areas, tighten to 1 sensor per 100–200 ft².
• Group 8–16 luminaires per sensor where practical.

These ranges come from field experience and align with guidance in the DOE wireless occupancy sensor applications guide, which emphasizes that sensor density must increase in complex layouts and higher mounting heights.

Why it matters:

• Too few sensors → large dark patches, slow response, and user complaints.
• Too many fixtures per sensor → lights stay on in large areas whenever a single corner is occupied.

Sample zoning table for high-bay layouts

Space type	Typical ceiling height	Recommended sensor coverage	Typical fixtures per zone	Notes
Open warehouse bay	25–40 ft	200–400 ft² per sensor	8–16	Use high-bay PIR or microwave sensors rated for mounting height
Narrow picking aisles	20–35 ft	100–200 ft² per sensor	4–8	Use aisle-way lenses; avoid cross-aisle triggering
Production / assembly	18–30 ft	150–300 ft² per sensor	6–12	Consider task tuning to 70–80% max output
Indoor sports / gym	25–40 ft	300–500 ft² per sensor	10–20	Balance energy savings with play safety; longer timeouts

These are design starting points, not code mandates, but they have proven effective for projects aiming to meet the illuminance recommendations in ANSI/IES RP‑7 for industrial facilities.

3.2 Primary patterns: rows, blocks, and task islands

Most compliant designs for high-bay spaces use some combination of three patterns:

1. Row zoning (by luminaire row)

   • Common for open warehouses and big-box style spaces.
   • Each row of high bays is its own zone, on both occupancy and daylight.
   • Simplifies commissioning because zones map visually to what people see.

2. Block zoning (by functional area)

   • Used when the task layout cuts across rows (e.g., end-of-aisle packing stations).
   • Group 2–4 rows together as one occupancy/daylight zone that matches a business function.

3. Task islands

   • Small clusters around high-value tasks: QC tables, loading docks, or maintenance bays.
   • Often implemented as 1–4 fixtures on a dedicated sensor or even a local override switch.

In many code-compliant projects, row zoning covers 80% of luminaires, with task islands and special zones making up the remaining 20%.

3.3 Pro Tip: Don’t oversize “mega-zones”

A recurring failure mode in real projects is the temptation to minimize hardware: “Can we put the whole 30,000 ft² bay on three sensors?”

Practitioners who tried this repeatedly ended up with:

• Long “lit but empty” zones because one corner stayed occupied.
• Frequent complaints that lights turn off while a worker is still in a distant aisle.

Field experience shows that finer zoning (more, smaller zones) typically improves both comfort and savings. Even a 15–20% increase in device count often pays back quickly through:

• 10–25% additional energy savings from better shutoff and task tuning.
• Faster commissioning because each zone is simpler to debug.

---

4. Daylight Zoning: Aligning Controls With Real Sunlight

Daylight controls are where many ASHRAE 90.1 and IECC projects stumble. The issue is almost always zoning—not the sensor brand.

4.1 How codes define daylight zones

Both ASHRAE 90.1 and IECC define primary and sometimes secondary daylight zones near vertical glazing and under skylights. IECC 2024’s commercial chapter on lighting efficiency explicitly expands where daylight-responsive controls are required in sidelit and toplight areas per IECC 2024 Chapter 4.

In practice, this means:

• A strip of floor area adjacent to windows (depth based on ceiling height and window dimensions) is a mandatory daylight control zone.
• For skylights, a circular or rectangular region around each opening is zoned separately.

4.2 Practical sizing: follow the daylight line, not the wall

A common mistake is to define daylight zones as “the first two rows of fixtures along the wall.” In reality, the daylight penetration line depends on ceiling height, window head height, and exterior shading.

From real projects and rules-of-thumb aligned with DOE FEMP guidance on SSL solutions:

• For offices or low-bay spaces with 10–12 ft ceilings, daylight often reaches 8–12 ft into the space effectively.
• For high-bay spaces (25–35 ft ceiling), usable daylight penetration can extend farther but also becomes patchier; careful sensor positioning is critical.

Design move:
Map the actual daylight pattern during site visits or in simulation (using IES files in AGi32 or similar tools). Then zone fixtures along the daylight boundary, not just by counting rows.

4.3 Sensor placement and grouping for daylight

Practical rules for daylight zoning:

1. One daylight sensor per orientation and height band

   • Group windows with similar orientation and shading into one control loop where possible.
   • Avoid mixing north-facing and west-facing facades in a single daylight zone.

2. Limit fixtures per daylight sensor

   • Keep to 8–16 fixtures per daylight control loop in large spaces.
   • For mixed tasks (e.g., office + production), use separate loops even if they share the same glazing.

3. Commissioning protocol
   Based on practical commissioning checklists and consistent with good practice outlined in NREL’s high-performance building best-practices manual:

   • Record pre-control and post-control illuminance at task height (e.g., 30 in workplane) at multiple points.
   • Set daylight setpoints with shades/blinds closed first, then verify behavior with blinds open.
   • Document sensor addresses, zones, and final setpoints.

These steps not only satisfy inspectors but also prevent future “mystery behavior” when building staff inherit the system.

---

5. Occupancy Zoning: Balancing Sensitivity, Nuisance, and Code

5.1 Classifying the control circuits correctly

From a safety and wiring perspective, zoning is constrained by the National Electrical Code (NEC). NFPA 70, summarized in this NEC overview, defines minimum standards for branch circuits, overcurrent protection, and control wiring separation.

In practice for 0–10 V controlled LED luminaires:

• Treat control conductors according to their Class 1 / Class 2 rating and follow separation rules.
• Do not mix line-voltage dimming and low-voltage 0–10 V circuits on the same fixtures unless specifically allowed by the driver and controls documentation.

Poorly planned zones often result in unmanageable mixed wiring, making NEC compliance and troubleshooting much harder.

5.2 Zoning by activity pattern

Start zoning from how the space is used, not from the panel schedule:

• Constant-traffic areas (main aisles, production lines)

  • Use larger zones with longer timeouts (e.g., 20–30 min).
  • Controls can be occupancy- or schedule-driven with vacancy-trim dimming.

• Intermittent-use areas (storage corners, maintenance bays)

  • Use smaller zones with shorter timeouts (e.g., 5–15 min).
  • Prefer dedicated occupancy sensors per bay.

• Safety-critical paths (egress paths, dock edges)

  • Coordinate with life-safety requirements; these zones may need higher minimum light levels and less aggressive shutoff.

5.3 Expert Warning: Long 0–10 V runs break zone behavior

One of the most common field issues with zoned dimming is inconsistent dim levels across a “zone” that shares a long 0–10 V control run.

From practical experience with industrial projects:

• Keep each 0–10 V run under ~100 m (330 ft) where possible to avoid voltage drop and noise.
• Use a dedicated twisted pair for each control zone; do not daisy-chain unrelated zones on the same pair.
• Ensure a clean, consistent reference (ground) across the control system.

If long runs are unavoidable (large warehouses, campuses), the fix is to:

• Introduce local control modules or repeaters near fixture groups.
• Consider migrating to a digital protocol (e.g., DALI or a networked control platform) where zoning is logical, not just wired.

Skipping this step often leads to:

• Some fixtures never reaching full output.
• Others failing to dim below 40–50%, which violates multi-level control intent.

---

6. Putting It Together: A Step-by-Step Zoning Workflow

To make this actionable, here is a repeatable process that has worked across warehouses, gyms, and manufacturing spaces.

6.1 Step 1 – Start from tasks and illuminance targets

Use an application standard such as ANSI/IES RP‑7 to determine target illuminance and uniformity for each area (e.g., 30–50 fc typical for many warehouse aisles, higher for fine assembly).

Then:

• Map task types and boundaries: aisles, bulk storage, docks, inspection zones.
• Identify safety-critical areas that may require higher minimum light levels.

Zoning should never compromise achieving these targets.

6.2 Step 2 – Overlay code-required control types

For each task area, list which controls are required:

• Automatic shutoff? (Yes in almost all commercial spaces.)
• Multi-level / continuous dimming? (Typically yes for interior spaces > a given size.)
• Daylight response? (Only if daylight zones exist.)

This simple matrix quickly shows where separate zones are mandatory.

Sample zoning requirements matrix

Area	Auto shutoff	Multi-level/dimming	Daylight response	Recommended zone type
Open pallet storage	Yes	Yes	No	Row/block zones by bay
Windowed picking aisles	Yes	Yes	Yes	Row zones aligned to daylight bands
Interior picking aisles	Yes	Yes	No	Aisle-by-aisle zones
Loading docks (overhead doors)	Yes	Yes	Maybe (if doors glazed)	Task islands per dock door
Mezzanine offices	Yes	Yes	Often yes	Room-by-room zones

6.3 Step 3 – Design sensor and switch placement

Once the matrix is set:

1. Place occupancy sensors

   • Follow manufacturer-recommended mounting heights and coverage patterns, consistent with DOE’s wireless occupancy sensor guide.
   • Ensure overlapping coverage in critical zones (e.g., fork paths).
   • Adjust density to the 200–400 ft² guideline for open areas and 100–200 ft² for aisles.

2. Place daylight sensors

   • One per orientation/daylight band; avoid mixing highly divergent daylight conditions.
   • Locate sensors where they see representative light, not hidden in deep soffits.

3. Assign local overrides

   • Provide local control stations per enclosed space as required by code.
   • In large open areas, provide strategic overrides (e.g., dock supervisor station) for operational flexibility.

6.4 Step 4 – Wire and document the zones logically

At rough-in and trim-out, insist on documentation that matches reality:

• Circuit schedules labeled with zone names (e.g., “Aisle 3 – Daylight Zone 1”).
• 0–10 V runs labeled at junction boxes and panels.
• Sensor addresses and bindings recorded in as-built drawings.

This documentation is not just good practice; it is frequently requested during inspections and is essential for long-term facility management. The importance of robust documentation is echoed in federal guidance such as the GSA LED lighting and controls guidance, which stresses the role of commissioning and documentation in realizing energy savings.

6.5 Step 5 – Commission with measurements, not just “looks good”

Effective commissioning combines subjective checks with quantitative data:

• Measure illuminance at task height in multiple locations per zone at 100%, tuned level (e.g., 70–80%), and daylight-dimmed levels.
• Verify auto-off times match the design (e.g., 15 minutes in intermittent areas, 30 minutes in main aisles), within code limits.
• Confirm that daylight zones reduce power according to code requirements when sufficient daylight is present.

Recording pre/post energy use (kWh or demand) strengthens rebate applications and creates a baseline for future improvements.

---

7. Myth vs. Reality in Control Zoning

Myth 1: “One sensor for the whole room is the simplest way to pass code.”

Reality: A single large zone may technically meet automatic shutoff requirements, but it often fails user expectations and undermines energy savings. Smaller, well-targeted zones improve both comfort and kWh reduction.

Myth 2: “If I have a photocell at the panel, I’ve satisfied daylighting requirements.”

Reality: ASHRAE 90.1 and IECC require area-based daylight zones with specific dimming behavior. A single exterior photocell that turns everything on/off at sunset does not satisfy daylight-responsive dimming requirements in primary and secondary daylight zones.

Myth 3: “Daylight controls only matter in offices; warehouses don’t need them.”

Reality: Many modern industrial buildings have large clerestories or skylights. Codes increasingly require daylight-responsive controls in these spaces, and case studies summarized in the DOE Interior Lighting Campaign report show significant additional savings—often 20–40% over efficient luminaires alone—when controls are properly zoned and commissioned.

---

8. Zoning for Rebates and Future-Proofing

8.1 Why utilities care about your zoning

Utility incentive programs typically follow the technical baselines and savings assumptions from organizations like the DesignLights Consortium and the U.S. Department of Energy. To qualify for higher-tier rebates:

• Luminaires often must be DLC-qualified.
• Controls—especially occupancy and daylight zoning—are a key part of the savings calculations.

Programs cataloged in tools such as the DSIRE database of state incentives often provide higher incentives when projects include high-efficacy luminaires plus advanced controls.

8.2 Bundling documentation with quotes

In practice, rebate reviewers ask first for:

• Fixture specification sheets and IES/LM-79 data.
• DLC listing references.
• A controls narrative and sometimes a zoning diagram.

Including a simple zoning diagram and explanation with your bid—showing occupancy and daylight zones—can cut approval time significantly and avoid redesign late in the project.

---

9. Quick Configuration Template: Zoning Checklist

Use this as a field-ready template when planning a code-compliant project.

1. List spaces and tasks

   • For each zone candidate, note: task type, target fc/lux, occupancy pattern.

2. Determine code-required controls

   • Auto shutoff (schedule vs. occupancy vs. both).
   • Multi-level/dimming (on/off vs. stepped vs. continuous).
   • Daylight-responsive (yes/no; primary/secondary zones).

3. Draft zones on plan

   • Start with row zones; refine to blocks and task islands.
   • Align daylight zones with daylight penetration, not wall lines.

4. Size and place sensors

   • 200–400 ft² per sensor for open high-bay spaces.
   • 100–200 ft² per sensor for aisles and detailed tasks.
   • Group 8–16 luminaires per occupancy/daylight sensor where practical.

5. Plan control wiring

   • Keep 0–10 V runs < 100 m where possible.
   • Use dedicated control pairs per zone; avoid mixing protocols or driver types.

6. Document and label

   • Name every zone logically on drawings and in the control system.
   • Record sensor addresses, timeouts, dim levels, and daylight setpoints.

7. Commission with measurements

   • Verify code-required behaviors and timeouts.
   • Log pre/post illuminance and, when possible, energy data.

Following this checklist usually moves a project from “likely to pass” to “easy to defend” in front of inspectors, owners, and rebate reviewers.

---

10. Key Takeaways

• Zones are behavioral contracts. Each control zone is a promise about how a part of the building will behave under code: when lights turn off, how they dim, and how they respond to daylight.
• Start from tasks and daylight, not from panel schedules. Map tasks and daylight patterns first, then overlay code requirements to define zones.
• Right-size control zones. Target 200–400 ft² per high-bay sensor and 8–16 fixtures per zone as a practical range, tightening for aisles and detailed tasks.
• Respect wiring realities. NEC requirements and 0–10 V voltage drop place real limits on how large a wired zone can be.
• Commission like you mean it. Measure illuminance, verify behaviors, and document everything; this is where ASHRAE 90.1 and IECC compliance becomes verifiable.
• Leverage zoning for rebates. Properly zoned controls plus high-efficacy luminaires can unlock substantial incentives available through programs indexed in DSIRE and similar databases.

With a disciplined zoning strategy, you convert energy code requirements from a design constraint into a roadmap for efficient, comfortable, and future-ready lighting.

---

FAQ: Control Zoning for ASHRAE 90.1 & IECC

Q1. How small should a control zone be to meet ASHRAE 90.1?
ASHRAE 90.1 does not specify a maximum zone size. Instead, it defines behaviors (automatic shutoff, dimming, daylight response by area). In practice, 200–400 ft² per occupancy sensor for high-bay open areas and 100–200 ft² for aisles offers a good balance between savings and usability.

Q2. Do I always need daylight sensors in a warehouse?
No. Daylight-responsive zones are required only where the building has qualifying daylight areas—facades with significant glazing or skylights. However, many modern industrial buildings do have these, and IECC 2024 expands the scope of required daylight controls, so early evaluation is important.

Q3. Can I use one photocell for both daylight dimming and nighttime on/off?
For interior daylight zones, codes require controls that respond to interior daylight conditions, often with continuous dimming. A single exterior photocell used only to turn lights on at sunset generally does not meet the requirements for interior daylight-responsive control zones.

Q4. How do I prove my zones comply during inspection?
Provide a control narrative, zoning plan, and as-built documentation showing which fixtures belong to which occupancy and daylight zones, plus commissioning records (timeouts, dim levels, daylight setpoints). Inspectors are typically satisfied when they see clear documentation and can verify a few sample behaviors on site.

Q5. How do zoning decisions affect rebates?
Many utility programs base incentive levels on both fixture efficacy and the sophistication of controls. Projects that combine DLC-listed luminaires with well-documented occupancy and daylight zoning often qualify for higher incentives, as reflected in programs cataloged by the DSIRE database.

---

Safety disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. It does not constitute engineering, electrical, or legal advice. Always consult applicable codes (such as ASHRAE 90.1, IECC, NFPA 70/NEC) and work with licensed design professionals and electricians familiar with local amendments before designing or installing lighting control systems.