Why Is My Photocell Sensor Staying On During the Day?

Outdoor dusk‑to‑dawn photocells are supposed to save energy and maintenance time. When they fail “ON” and your parking lot, barn, or wall packs burn all day, they do the opposite: waste power, shorten fixture life, and trigger nuisance calls.

This guide walks through a proven, field-tested process to diagnose a photocell that keeps lights on during the day. It is written for electricians, facility managers, and technically minded DIY users who want a methodical, code-conscious approach rather than guesswork.

Safety first
Always de‑energize circuits before opening junction boxes or changing wiring. Follow the National Electrical Code (NEC) and local electrical codes, and use lockout/tagout where required. Always wear appropriate Personal Protective Equipment (PPE), such as insulated gloves and safety glasses, when working with live circuits.

1. How a dusk‑to‑dawn photocell is supposed to work

Before troubleshooting, it helps to anchor expectations.

Most line‑voltage photocells used on outdoor luminaires:

• Are rated for 120 V, 120–277 V, or 347–480 V
• Use a solid‑state or relay output that closes at low light (turning lights ON) and opens at higher light (turning lights OFF)
• Include a built‑in time delay (often 30–120 seconds) to ride through brief light changes
• Switch based on illuminance, typically:
  • Turn ON around 5–20 lux (≈0.5–2 foot‑candles)
  • Turn OFF around 30–60 lux (≈3–6 foot‑candles)

According to an example dusk‑to‑dawn barn light datasheet summarized in the Onforu user manual, many controls are configured to turn ON at about 10–20 lux and OFF at 30–60 lux, with a deliberate gap (hysteresis) to prevent short‑cycling. That means a sensor mounted under a deep canopy or eave may still “see night” even at noon if the surface never reaches those OFF levels.

What “stuck ON” actually means

In the field, “photocell is on during the day” usually falls into one of three technical conditions:

1. Relay closed all the time – the photocell has failed or is miswired, so full line voltage is always present at the load.
2. Control is working, but never sees enough light – orientation, shading, or site changes keep lux below the OFF threshold.
3. Control is technically OFF, but LEDs still glow – tiny leakage current holds LED drivers partially energized.

The diagnostic steps below separate those cases quickly.

2. Quick checks you can do from the ground

These are the low‑risk, no‑ladder steps that often reveal the root cause.

2.1 Visual scan of the site

Walk the site in daylight and at dusk if possible, and note:

• Sensor location and orientation

  • Is the photocell under an eave or canopy?
  • Is it facing north into a dark alley, under trees, or into a light well?
  • Is it pointing directly at another luminaire or window?

• Surrounding surfaces

  • White roofs, snow, or light concrete can reflect light into sensors.
  • Dark paint, new awnings, or added shades can dramatically reduce lux at the sensor.

• Recent changes

  • New building additions, repainted facades, added carports, or adjacent structures that may have changed how much light reaches the photocell.

Expert warning (orientation trap)
Installers sometimes assume misalignment only makes a photocell “slow” to react. In practice, a north‑facing sensor tucked under an overhang may never experience true daytime illuminance. Field experience confirms that no amount of cleaning or replacement will fix an always‑on complaint until the sensor is moved into a realistic daylight view.

2.2 Simple “cover test”

A rapid isolation trick from field practice:

1. Use a thick glove for safety, or a small piece of opaque cloth.
2. Cover the photocell completely during full daylight and watch the lights.
3. Wait at least 60–90 seconds to bypass the internal time delay.

Interpretation:

• Lights turn OFF when you uncover, and ON when you cover

  • The photocell is responding. Focus on orientation and shading.
  • The site may be genuinely below its OFF threshold during the day.

• Lights stay ON regardless of covering

  • Either the control has failed closed, is bypassed, or wiring/backfeed is keeping the circuit energized.

This small test alone often tells whether you are dealing with optics (positioning) or power (wiring or failed control).

3. Common causes of a photocell staying ON

3.1 Incorrect wiring patterns

For commercial sites especially, wiring errors are a leading hidden cause.

Typical mistakes seen on dusk‑to‑dawn retrofits:

• Line/load reversal – Line (incoming hot) and load (outgoing hot to luminaires) swapped on the photocell. Many controls will still pass power but never break properly.
• Switched neutral – The neutral is switched instead of the hot conductor, leaving fixtures energized relative to ground.
• Shared or borrowed neutrals – Two circuits share a neutral, backfeeding current into the “off” leg when the other circuit is active.
• Bypassed photocell – Someone tied line and load together for temporary override and never restored control.

The National Electrical Code, summarized in the NFPA 70 overview, treats correct conductor identification and overcurrent protection as a minimum safety baseline. Miswired photocell circuits can leave energized parts where users expect them to be dead, so treat any suspected miswiring as both an operational and safety defect.

Pro tip (backfeed vs. “bad sensor”)
A common finding in commercial installations is that line/load miswiring or shared neutrals cause more "stuck-on" issues than dirty lenses. In practice, a photocell can appear to have failed even though its relay opens; the luminaires continue to glow because they are being fed from another circuit.

3.2 Photocell failure mode: why “fail ON” is intentional

Solid‑state controls and relay‑type photocells are often designed to fail in the closed (ON) position by default. This reflects a common failure pattern: after a surge or moisture intrusion, the internal contacts may weld closed or the electronics may short, leaving the load permanently energized.

From a safety standpoint this is deliberate: it is usually safer for exterior egress and security lighting to stay on than to go dark unexpectedly. The downside is increased energy use and lamp degradation until the fault is corrected.

3.3 Environmental and optical issues

Even when wiring and hardware are sound, the environment can trick a sensor into permanent “night”:

• Deep canopies and soffits – Facades under overhangs may only see a small fraction of sky brightness. Photosensors mounted here may never reach 30–60 lux.
• Obstructions – Tree growth, new signage, or even bird nests can shade a photocell.
• Reflective feedback loops – Building‑mounted luminaires shining onto a roof‑mounted sensor can make it oscillate or stay “night” if the sensor sees its own circuit’s light instead of the sky.
• Site modifications – Darker exterior paint or added privacy screens reduce reflected daylight.

According to the DesignLights Consortium guidance for exterior controls, proper sensor siting and shielding are prerequisites for achieving reliable dusk‑to‑dawn behavior, especially for parking lots and area lighting. That same principle applies on a smaller scale to wall packs and barn lights.

3.4 Leakage and ghost‑glow with LED drivers

With legacy HID (high‑intensity discharge) fixtures, a failed‑open photocell usually meant darkness. LEDs behave differently.

Modern LED drivers are very efficient. They can partially energize from very small leakage currents—hundreds of microamps—coming through:

• Status LEDs in controls
• Surge protection devices
• Long cable runs with capacitive coupling
• Test switches or pilot lights

Field diagnostics often show that a visible “ON” condition can exist even when a photocell is technically OFF. The control’s output may be open, but leakage elsewhere keeps the driver active enough for a noticeable glow, especially at night or in shaded locations.

In these cases, installing an interposing relay or a photocell with better leakage immunity (or adding a small resistive bleed where permitted) can fully de‑energize the drivers.

4. Step‑by‑step diagnostic workflow

For electricians or maintenance techs, a structured workflow saves repeat visits and reduces random part swaps.

4.1 Tools you should have on hand

• True RMS multimeter with a CAT III 600V or higher safety rating, suitable for the system voltage.
• Clamp meter with a milliamp (mA) AC range to accurately measure low leakage currents. A CAT III 600V rating is recommended.
• Voltage tester (non-contact or solenoid type).
• Insulated hand tools (screwdrivers, pliers) rated for 1000V.
• Appropriate PPE, including insulated gloves, safety glasses (or face shield), and flame-resistant (FR) clothing where required by site safety protocols.
• Camera or mobile device for documenting settings and wiring.

4.2 Diagnostic decision tree

Use this sequence for a typical line‑voltage photocell controlling one or more fixtures.

Step 1 – Confirm the complaint and operating window

• Visit the site when there is clearly sufficient daylight (e.g., around solar noon) and the lights should be OFF.
• Note any manual overrides at panels, contactors, or switches.

Step 2 – Perform the cover/uncover test

• As described earlier, fully cover the sensor for at least 60–90 seconds.
• If the lights respond, focus on optics/orientation; if not, proceed to electrical checks.

Step 3 – Measure voltage at the photocell

Safety Warning: This step involves working with live circuits. Wear appropriate PPE, including insulated gloves and safety glasses. Ensure your multimeter is set to the correct AC voltage range (e.g., 400V or 1000V setting) and that your test leads are in good condition.

With power on and the enclosure safely accessible:

1. Measure line to neutral (or line to line) at the input terminals. Confirm expected voltage (e.g., ~120 V or ~208–277 V).
2. Measure load to neutral with the sensor exposed to daylight (i.e., it should be “OFF”).

Interpret readings:

Condition	Likely cause	Next move
Full line voltage present on load with daylight	Relay welded closed or line/load jumpered	Replace photocell or correct bypass wiring
0 V on load with daylight, lights still glowing	Leakage elsewhere keeping drivers alive	Check for shared neutrals, surge devices, or add relay/bleeder
Voltage drops only partially (e.g., from 120 V to 30–60 V)	Miswired neutral or series leakage path	Inspect splices and shared neutrals in junction boxes

Step 4 – Isolate the load

To distinguish a failed control from backfeed on the load side:

1. De‑energize the circuit.
2. Disconnect the load conductor from the photocell output. Cap it safely.
3. Re‑energize the circuit and measure voltage on the load terminal of the photocell with daylight present.

• If the load terminal still shows full line voltage, the photocell is not opening. Replace it.
• If the load terminal is open (0 V relative to neutral), but the disconnected load conductor still shows voltage, another circuit is backfeeding the luminaires.

Step 5 – Check for residual current

Using a clamp meter on the load conductor with the photocell “OFF” (in daylight):

Set your clamp meter to the lowest AC current range (e.g., 40mA or similar) to detect small leakage currents.

• Current greater than a few milliamps suggests real load or backfeed.
• Sub‑milliamp currents (typically <1 mA) indicate driver leakage sensitivity; most HID systems never reacted to this, but LEDs often do.

If a separate relay or contactor is already present, inspect its coil control and auxiliary contacts as well.

Step 6 – Temporarily bypass the photocell

As a final confirmation:

1. De‑energize.
2. Tie line and load together (bypass the photocell) using a suitable wirenut or temporary jumper.
3. Re‑energize and verify that all luminaires behave as expected (uniform ON).

If bypassing the control produces stable operation and the sensor wiring is correct, the photocell itself is defective or mis‑specified for the application (e.g., wrong voltage rating, insufficient surge robustness).

5. Consolidated Troubleshooting Table

Use this table for quick on-site diagnosis.

Symptom	Likely Cause(s)	Key Diagnostic Test	Solution
Lights are always ON, day and night. Cover test has no effect.	1. Failed photocell (welded relay). 2. Photocell is bypassed (wiring). 3. Line/Load conductors reversed.	Voltage Test: With the circuit energized and sensor uncovered in daylight, measure voltage at the photocell's LOAD terminal. If full line voltage is present, de-energize, disconnect the load wire, re-energize, and measure the LOAD terminal again.	If voltage is still present on the empty terminal, the photocell has failed. Replace it. If voltage is gone, the issue is in the wiring (backfeed or bypass). Trace and correct wiring.
Lights are always ON, but respond correctly to the cover test.	1. Incorrect sensor orientation (e.g., north-facing, under a deep eave). 2. Sensor is shaded by an obstruction (tree, sign). 3. Lux OFF-setpoint is too high (on adjustable models).	Light Measurement: Use a lux meter at the sensor's lens during full daylight. Compare the reading to the photocell's specified OFF threshold (typically 30–60 lux).	Relocate the sensor to a position with a clear, unobstructed view of the sky. Remove any obstructions. If the control is adjustable, lower the OFF threshold.
LED lights glow dimly during the day when they should be OFF.	1. Leakage current from the control's electronics. 2. Shared/borrowed neutral from another energized circuit. 3. Capacitive coupling in long wire runs.	Current Test: With the sensor OFF in daylight, use a clamp meter (on mA setting) on the load wire. Voltage Test: Voltage at the load terminal should be 0V. If not, investigate miswiring.	A small current reading (<5 mA) confirms leakage. Solutions: 1. Isolate circuit neutrals. 2. Install an interposing relay. 3. Use a photocell designed for LED loads (low leakage).
Lights cycle ON and OFF (short-cycle) at dusk or dawn.	1. Light from the fixture(s) is reflecting back onto the sensor. 2. The photocell lacks an adequate time delay.	Observation: Watch the sensor's location relative to the light it controls as it activates. Temporarily shield the sensor from the fixture's light to see if cycling stops.	Relocate or shield the sensor to break the reflective loop. Replace the unit with a photocell that has a built-in time delay (e.g., 30–120 seconds).

6. Matching and replacing a problem photocell

When replacement is justified, specifying the right control prevents repeat failures.

6.1 Voltage and load ratings

Use the nameplate and panel schedule to determine:

• System voltage: 120 V, 120–277 V, or 347–480 V are common.
• Maximum load current or wattage of the connected luminaires.

A frequent field problem is mixing 120 V‑only controls on 120–277 V circuits. A photocell hit with overvoltage can fail partially—still passing current but no longer responding to light—mimicking a stuck‑ON failure. Always match or exceed the system voltage rating.

6.2 Environmental ratings

Exterior controls must match the fixture’s exposure:

• Temperature range suitable for local climate (cold‑weather sites demand low‑temperature ratings).
• Ingress protection (IP) or NEMA enclosure rating aligned with exposure to rain, snow, and dust.
  The IEC 60529 IP rating standard defines levels of protection against solids and liquids; for open outdoor locations, pairing an IP65 luminaire with equivalently robust controls is a practical baseline.

6.3 Control features that improve reliability

On busy commercial or industrial sites, consider controls with:

• Adjustable lux thresholds – to fine‑tune ON/OFF points if the mounting location is partially shaded.
• Time‑delay filters – to avoid nuisance switching from car headlights or sporadic reflections.
• Integrated surge protection – photocells exposed on a pole top are vulnerable to surges that can weld contacts.
• Replaceable modules – twist‑lock or plug‑in units simplify future service.

The U.S. Department of Energy’s FEMP guidance on LED luminaires notes that exterior lighting systems designed for efficiency should be paired with reliable automatic controls. For dusk‑to‑dawn applications, that means controls capable of maintaining performance over years of thermal cycling and surge exposure, not just meeting initial specs.

7. Case studies: what typically goes wrong

Case 1 – “Bad photocell” that wasn’t bad

A warehouse reports that their wall‑mounted luminaires stay on all day. Two photocell replacements have not fixed the issue.

On site:

• Sensors are under a deep canopy, facing north toward a shaded loading dock.
• Midday illuminance at the sensor lens measures ~12 lux—within a nighttime ON range for many controls.

Fix:

• Sensors are relocated to the top of the facade, angled slightly upward toward open sky.
• OFF threshold adjusted to a mid‑range setting.
• Lights now switch OFF reliably by early morning and back ON at dusk.

Result: no hardware failures, only an orientation and threshold problem.

Case 2 – Retrofit with shared neutral backfeeding LEDs

A mixed‑use property upgraded HID parking lot heads to LED. Afterward, the entire circuit appears stuck ON in the day.

Findings:

• Panel shows multi‑wire branch circuits with shared neutrals.
• A separate building circuit was accidentally tied into the same neutral bundle.
• With the photocell relay open, a few milliamps still flow through LED drivers via the other circuit’s neutral, making them glow.

Fix:

• Circuits separated, neutrals corrected to match their respective breakers.
• Photocell verified to open cleanly; glow disappears once backfeed is removed.

This scenario aligns with the field observations mentioned earlier: wiring interactions and leakage, not just failed controls, can keep LEDs visibly energized.

Case 3 – Overvoltage‑damaged photocell

A 120–277 V LED area lighting circuit received a replacement photocell labeled only for 120 V.

Symptoms:

• Worked normally for a short period.
• After a storm, all luminaires remained ON in daylight.
• Cover test showed no response.

Testing:

• Line to load measured full system voltage regardless of light level.
• Internal contacts found welded closed upon teardown.

Fix:

• Correctly rated 120–277 V photocell installed.
• Surge protection added at the panel feeder.

This mirrors the partial-damage pattern described earlier: controls can survive long enough to confuse diagnosis, then fail closed.

8. Preventing repeat issues: design and documentation

8.1 Installation best practices

When designing or installing new dusk‑to‑dawn controls:

• Mount with a clear view of the sky

  • Avoid deep recesses, soffits, and shaded alcoves.
  • Slight upward tilt helps the sensor see true ambient daylight instead of wall reflections.

• Avoid self‑lighting

  • Position sensors so they cannot see the luminaires they control. Use shields if necessary.

• Follow NEC and manufacturer wiring diagrams

  • Keep line, load, and neutral conductors clearly identified.
  • Use listed connectors and weather‑rated junction boxes for exterior splices.

The NEMA Lighting Controls terminology guide standardizes terms like “photosensor,” “daylight control,” and “time delay.” Using consistent language in drawings and labels reduces misunderstanding between designers, installers, and maintenance staff.

8.2 Documenting fixes and settings

Every time a photocell issue is corrected, capture:

• Sensor type and voltage rating
• Orientation (e.g., “south facing, 10° up”) and mounting location
• Lux level at the sensor at noon on a clear day (if you have a meter)
• Wiring corrections performed
• Date and technician name

This simple log helps future techs avoid “starting over” and is particularly valuable for portfolio managers comparing performance across multiple sites.

8.3 Integrating with broader control strategies

In larger facilities, photocells are often only one layer of the control stack, alongside motion sensors and dimming. For those systems, pairing this troubleshooting workflow with guidance on motion and daylight sensors—for example, the layering approaches outlined in resources like the article on combining motion and daylight sensors for high bays—helps build a resilient, code‑compliant control scheme.

9. Common myths about “stuck‑on” photocells

Myth 1: If the light is always on, the photocell relay is dead.
Reality: As discussed, LED drivers can glow from tiny leakage currents, and miswiring or shared neutrals frequently keep circuits energized even with a healthy control.

Myth 2: Cleaning the sensor fixes most problems.
Reality: Dirt can affect performance, but field experience shows that in many commercial cases, wiring errors and backfeed are the dominant causes. Always verify wiring before assuming sensor optics.

Myth 3: Any photocell with the right voltage will work.
Reality: Voltage is only the starting point. Environmental rating, surge immunity, lux thresholds, and load characteristics all matter. Overlooking these factors leads to repeat failures and nuisance trips.

10. Quick troubleshooting checklist

Use this as a field reference when a photocell stays ON during the day.

1. Verify safety – Lockout/tagout as required; confirm absence of voltage before handling conductors.
2. Visual inspection – Note orientation, shading, and recent site changes.
3. Cover test – Does the control respond to cover/uncover in daylight after a short delay?
4. Measure at the control – Line, load, and neutral voltages with the sensor “OFF.”
5. Isolate the load – Disconnect load at the photocell; check for backfeed on the load side.
6. Check residual current – Clamp the load conductor with photocell OFF; identify leakage vs true load.
7. Confirm system voltage – Ensure the photocell rating matches the circuit (120, 120–277, or 347–480 V).
8. Review environmental rating – IP/NEMA rating suitable for location; look for moisture or corrosion.
9. Document findings – Record what was measured, what was changed, and the final configuration.

Applying this structure typically allows a competent electrician or facility technician to resolve most “stuck‑on” dusk‑to‑dawn complaints in a single visit, without unnecessary replacements.

---

Frequently asked questions

Why do my LEDs stay dimly lit even when the photocell is OFF?
LED drivers can energize from very small leakage currents through surge protectors, indicator lamps, or capacitive coupling. The photocell may be fully open, but a few hundred microamps are enough for a visible glow. An interposing relay, correctly separated neutrals, or a control with better leakage characteristics usually solves it.

Can I just bypass the photocell permanently?
Technically yes, but you lose automatic dusk‑to‑dawn control, which increases energy consumption and may conflict with local energy codes such as ASHRAE 90.1 or IECC in some jurisdictions. Bypass is best reserved as a temporary diagnostic step or emergency override.

Is it okay to use a higher‑voltage photocell on a lower‑voltage circuit?
Controls rated 120–277 V are generally fine on 120 V circuits, but always follow manufacturer documentation. Never use a lower‑voltage control on a higher‑voltage circuit.

How often should photocells be replaced?
There is no universal replacement interval. In harsh climates with frequent storms and wide temperature swings, field experience shows that photocells may last 5–10 years. Regular inspection for moisture intrusion and corrosion is more important than a fixed calendar schedule.

What lux level should I target for dusk‑to‑dawn operation?
Many controls are designed to turn ON around 10–20 lux and OFF around 30–60 lux. For shaded facades that never reach those OFF levels, either move the sensor or select an adjustable model and tune the threshold with a lux meter.

---

Disclaimer
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional electrical, safety, or legal advice. Always follow the National Electrical Code (NEC), local regulations, and manufacturer instructions, and consult a licensed electrician or qualified professional before working on electrical systems.

Sources

• Onforu LED Dusk‑to‑Dawn Barn Light Manual – example photocell lux thresholds and time‑delay behavior.
• NFPA 70 – National Electrical Code (overview) – outlines the role of the NEC as the minimum electrical safety standard.
• IEC 60529 – IP Ratings – defines protection levels against solids and liquids for enclosures.
• DesignLights Consortium – Qualified Products List – technical and application guidance for controlled, high‑performance exterior lighting.
• DOE FEMP – Purchasing Energy‑Efficient Commercial and Industrial LED Luminaires – emphasizes pairing LED luminaires with robust automatic control strategies.
• NEMA LSD 64 – Lighting Controls Terminology – standardized definitions for lighting control devices and functions.